www.radartutorial.eu www.radartutorial.eu Radar Basics

Doppler Filters

Σ
Σ channel
ΔAz
ΔAz channel
ΔEl
ΔEl channel
Clutter
Doppler Filter
Zero
Doppler Filter
Doppler Filter
Bank
Multiplexer

Figure 1: Block diagram of an MTI system in a radar with a monopulse antenna and digital receiver

Σ
Σ channel
ΔAz
ΔAz channel
ΔEl
ΔEl channel
Clutter
Doppler Filter
Zero
Doppler Filter
Doppler Filter
Bank
Multiplexer

Figure 1: Block diagram of an MTI system in a radar with a monopulse antenna and digital receiver

Σ
Σ channel
ΔAz
ΔAz channel
ΔEl
ΔEl channel

Figure 1: Block diagram of an MTI system in a radar with a monopulse antenna and digital receiver (interactive picture)

Table of Contents « Doppler Filters »
  1. Doppler Filters as Low-Pass Filters
  2. Doppler Filter Bank
  3. Multiplexing
  4. Jet Engine Modulation (JEM)

What Are Doppler Filters?

Doppler Filters

The magnitude of the Doppler frequency of an echo signal is evaluated using various Doppler filters. These filters can be implemented in hardware using resonant filters or as software algorithms after the received signals have been digitized.

In a fully coherent radar with a digital receiver and monopulse processing, the MTI system is more complex than in pseudo-coherent radars. In classical Moving Target Indication (MTI), the primary objective is to suppress stationary targets so that moving targets can be displayed. Moving Target Detection (MTD) goes a step further by evaluating different Doppler components to detect moving targets even in the presence of strong interfering signals. In practice, however, the boundary between these two terms is not always clearly defined. By analyzing characteristic movements of individual components, an MTD system may, under suitable conditions, even recognize an object that is stationary as a whole as a target of interest. At very high transmission frequencies (in the terahertz range: starting at 0.1 THz), for example, vibrations from a stationary vehicle with its engine running can produce additional Doppler components in the echo signal.

The effectiveness of different filter designs often depends on the magnitude of the Doppler frequency. Therefore, several filtering methods are frequently used in parallel, and their results are evaluated afterward. Selecting the most favorable filter output is intended to achieve the highest possible ratio of the desired signal to interference and noise (Signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio, SINR). This principle is comparable to the optimization performed by a matched (optimum) filter, although this does not mean that the entire filter arrangement is itself a matched filter. In monopulse processing, this signal processing must also be performed for all three receiving channels (Σ, ΔAz, and ΔEl).

Synchronization of the coherent oscillator (COHO) as used in a pseudo-coherent radar is no longer necessary. The component still referred to here as the coherent oscillator is essentially just a frequency divider that converts the frequency of the master oscillator to the required intermediate frequency (IF).

fD < fcut ⇒ vr ≤ 20 kn, 40 kn
zero-
doppler
filter
clutter-
doppler
filter
Amplitude
fD
1 kHz
2 kHz

Figure 2: Doppler filters acting as low-pass filters

fD < fcut ⇒ vr ≤ 20 kn, 40 kn
zero-
doppler
filter
clutter-
doppler
filter
Amplitude
fD
1 kHz
2 kHz

Figure 2: Doppler filters acting as low-pass filters; the indicated frequencies apply to an L-band radar

Doppler Filters as Low-Pass or High-Pass Filters

The Clutter Doppler Filter (CDF) and the Zero Doppler Filter (ZDF) operate according to the principles of familiar inter-pulse cancellation: the phases of echo signals from at least two pulse repetition periods are compared. When detecting interfering signals with low Doppler frequencies, both circuits exhibit low-pass characteristics with respect to radial velocity.

The Zero Doppler Filter can operate as a digital low-pass filter and detects signals with lower Doppler frequencies than echoes from targets having a radial velocity of approximately 20 knots. In this example, the next Doppler filter has a cutoff frequency corresponding to a radial velocity of 40 knots. Both filters use differently optimized detection thresholds to enable the detection of weak target echoes. Both types of filters also belong to the field of coherent pulse integration, since echo signals from several pulse repetition periods are combined while preserving phase information.

The term “low-pass characteristics” must be interpreted carefully in this context. Frequencies are not measured directly; instead, the phases of successive echo signals are compared first. However, the Doppler frequency can be inferred from their phase changes. The term low-pass therefore describes how the circuit responds to signals with different Doppler frequencies. Whether the complete system exhibits low-pass or high-pass characteristics depends on the specific circuit or software algorithm. If interference detected by a low-pass filter is subtracted from the mixture of input signals, the remaining desired signal exhibits high-pass characteristics.

The Zero Doppler Filter is often a second-order filter and primarily detects stationary targets and targets with very low Doppler frequencies. The Clutter Doppler Filter covers a wider range and additionally detects rain clouds moving with a wind-induced radial velocity between 20 and 40 knots. This corresponds to a speed range of 37 to 74 km/h, which is usually considerably lower than the speed of an aircraft. The velocity limits given here are examples for the filter arrangement shown. During normal operation, echoes identified as clutter by these filters should not appear on the radar display. If an echo is detected by the Clutter Doppler Filter but not by the Zero Doppler Filter, it should also be determined whether the echo originates from a volume target or a point target. For this purpose, the signals in neighboring range cells are also evaluated.

Doppler Filter Bank
negative
Doppler shift
positive
Doppler shift
Frequency
Target echo
Doppler filters
fZF
fD
Amplitude

Figure 3: Frequency distribution of a Doppler filter bank with only 8 Doppler filters shown.

Doppler Filter Bank
negative
Doppler shift
positive
Doppler shift
Frequency
Target echo
Doppler filters
fZF
fD
Amplitude

Figure 3: Frequency distribution of a Doppler filter bank with only 8 Doppler filters shown.

Doppler Filter Bank

The principle of these Doppler filters is based on the fact that an echo signal containing a Doppler shift deviates from the nominal intermediate frequency. This deviation can be detected by a frequency filter with band-pass characteristics. Unlike the phase comparison performed by the Zero Doppler Filter or Clutter Doppler Filter, this method directly evaluates the signal according to its frequency. However, the achievable frequency resolution depends on the available observation time. The filters also require a certain settling time before they can provide sufficiently accurate results. In contrast, the results of inter-pulse cancellation mainly concern low Doppler frequencies and would primarily produce responses in the two filters closest to the nominal intermediate frequency.

The individual Doppler filters are combined into a Doppler filter bank. For example, filter banks containing 8, 16, or 32 Doppler filters with staggered frequency responses can operate in parallel. The Doppler filters shown in Figure 1 have approximately the same design. Each Doppler filter has a passband centered on a particular frequency. A target can produce responses in several filters simultaneously if its echo contains multiple overlapping Doppler components. Such components can arise, for example, from jet engine modulation (see Figure 5). Detecting the different Doppler components is an important step in target identification.

However, the filters can distinguish only a limited number of Doppler components occurring simultaneously. Even a single target may generate several different Doppler frequencies. If several targets occupy the same range cell, it may not be possible to determine which of the detected Doppler frequencies belongs to each target.

Since frequency measurement takes place at the intermediate frequency, the filters are arranged above and below the nominal fZF. An echo without Doppler shift lies exactly at the nominal fZF. With a suitable frequency conversion arrangement, the direction of target motion can also be distinguished: objects moving away from the radar produce an echo frequency below the nominal intermediate frequency, while objects approaching the radar produce an echo frequency above it. With a different mixer configuration, this relationship may be reversed. At zero Doppler frequency, the two adjacent filters above and below fZF should produce approximately equal output signals. Even small frequency deviations can cause a noticeable amplitude difference between these two filters. This makes it possible to detect small Doppler shifts, provided that the observation time and filter characteristics allow sufficient frequency resolution.

Multiplexing

In land-based and shipborne radars, stationary-target clutter occurs predominantly at short ranges because of the curvature of the Earth's surface. Therefore, stationary-target suppression is often applied primarily in short-range operation. If the radar transmits three MTI pulse repetition periods in one direction, the echoes received during these periods are processed sequentially by the MTI system. Because the filters operate differently, their results become available at different times. A multiplexer is therefore useful at the interface to the radar signal processor.

long range
long range
short range

Figure 4: Radar timing sequence with three short-range pulse repetition periods for MTI processing.

long range
long range
short
range
short
range
short
range

Figure 4: Radar timing sequence with three short-range pulse repetition periods for MTI processing.

long range
long range
short
range
short
range
short
range

Figure 4: Radar timing sequence with three short-range pulse repetition periods for MTI processing.

The Doppler filters can produce an output signal during the current pulse repetition period. These filters are therefore also effective in long-range operation, where only one pulse repetition period is available for each antenna direction. Unlike filters based on phase comparison, they do not require several consecutive pulse repetition periods to produce a response. However, the short observation time limits the achievable measurement accuracy. The measured Doppler frequency allows an estimate of the target's radial velocity. This radial velocity is also referred to as the range rate, since it describes the rate of change in distance between the radar and the target. The range rate is important for the plot extractor and for establishing the window of expectation during the next antenna rotation.

The Clutter Doppler Filter, operating according to the Integrate-and-Dump method, can be arranged to provide results after the second pulse repetition period.

The Zero Doppler Filter is also used to detect and suppress clutter. It compares the phases of echo signals from three or more pulse repetition periods and can provide a result only during the final pulse repetition period, although it may offer more accurate discrimination of very small Doppler frequencies.

The multiplexer can therefore be controlled according to the pulse repetition period number: during each of the three periods, a different filter output is routed to the radar signal processor. The processor compares and evaluates these results and selects the most favorable one for further processing. The identity of the filter that provided the selected result is also stored.

Figure 5: Doppler spectra of an aircraft exhibiting jet engine modulation and a wind turbine exhibiting rotor blade modulation.

Jet Engine Modulation (JEM)

Doppler frequencies are not produced solely by reflections from the main surfaces of an aircraft. With increasing requirements for detecting stealth aircraft, radar systems are becoming more sensitive. As a result, even smaller reflecting surfaces, such as the compressor blades of a jet engine, can contribute measurable components to the echo signal. Because these blades rotate, their instantaneous radial velocity may differ from that of the aircraft as a whole. This produces additional, time-varying echo components with characteristic Doppler frequencies. This phenomenon is known as jet engine modulation (JEM). Consequently, several filters in the Doppler filter bank may respond simultaneously. The positions and strengths of these Doppler components depend, among other factors, on the target's aspect angle. Their characteristic distribution can be represented by a mathematical model and stored in a database. Like a fingerprint, this pattern can help identify the aircraft type. For this purpose, the measured Doppler components must be correlated with the stored patterns.

The rotating blades of wind turbines also produce additional Doppler components with characteristic properties. However, this phenomenon is generally referred to as micro-Doppler or rotor blade modulation, rather than jet engine modulation. The two spectra in Figure 5 illustrate how different rotating components can affect the frequency distribution of radar echoes.

Since the Doppler frequency depends on the transmitter's carrier frequency and the radar may operate at several different transmission frequencies, the measured Doppler frequencies must be normalized before they can be compared. This means that the influence of the transmission frequency must be removed. The simplest method is to divide the measured Doppler frequency by the current transmission frequency and then multiply the result by a specified reference frequency.

Figure 5: Doppler spectra of an aircraft exhibiting jet engine modulation and a wind turbine exhibiting rotor blade modulation.

Description of the Components in the Block Diagram